By Marty Jourard
Songs
are truly flexible creations. They can be performed in arrangements and styles
quite different from the original while still retaining the song's core
identity.Three such examples are Eric
Clapton's Unplugged version of "Layla," Joe Cocker's versions of the Beatles' "A Little Help From My
Friends" and the Boxtops' hit "The Letter." England's UB40 built
their entire career with reggae arrangements of pop tunes, including "Red
Red Wine," originally written and performed by Neil Diamond!
But
the most obvious example of a song's flexible nature is the ability to be
transposed into different keys, creating subtle and sometimes not-so-subtle
changes in "feel."
Learning how to transpose a song into a new keys is an
essential skill for every musician and songwriter.
As a working musician you've probably
encountered many situations where the song's original key is inappropriate due
to the singer's vocal range or to a particular instrumental lineup.
As a songwriter you may favor certain keys based on
your vocal range or ability on your instrument. Your own compositions may in
fact sound better in a key different than the one in which it was originally
written. We're going to look at a variety of musical situations that call for
an awareness of a song's key.
Recently, a guitarist friend of mine was hired by a
theatre group to be in an onstage glitter-rock band that performed throughout
the play backing up the the main character, a transvestite rock
singer. The musical score was originally written in keys appropriate for the
original-cast lead singer's vocal range. The actor/singer starring in the
current production had a much lower vocal range. Five tunes needed to be
transposed to lower keys. Four songs were easy to transpose for guitar by
simply determining the new chord names, but the fifth song's key was lowered a
whole-step from D major to C major, and this new and boring key effectively
eliminating all of the song's cool-sounding open guitar chords (D, G, A). For
this one particular song the guitarist used a guitar tuned down a whole-step
(D-G-C-F-A-D). The guitarist played the original chords, but they sounded a
whole-step lower, so the singer could hit the notes and the open chord voicings
were retained.
How do keyboard players transpose? Acoustic pianists have
no choice but to learn a new set of chords for a new key, but electronic
keyboard players can simply use the pitch transpose, a feature that raises or
lowers the pitch of the entire keyboard. As a keyboard player I've used this
trick but found that large transpositions can be a bit disorienting. You must
also remember to save the transposed preset with a name that reminds you of the
pitch change, such as PIANO+3 for a transposition of three half-steps up or
PIANO-2 for a shift down of a whole-step.
Singers in cover bands that perform current hits by
Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey and other full-range divas are often challenged
by the original too-high keys of the songs. To lower the key, find the highest
note in the original arrangement and make it match the highest note the singer
can hit. Count the difference in half-steps and locate this number on the
transposition chart. The letter-names
in the column beneath the particular number are the new chord names. For
example, a blues song in the key of D major contains the chords D7-G7-A7.
Lowering the song three half-steps(-3) to the key of B major leads us to the -3
column of the chart. Locate the D, G and A
in the middle column; the new chord letter-names are shown in the -3
column (B, E and F#). The chords of the blues song when transposed to the key
of B major are B7-E7-F#7.
Sometimes a song is in a great key for a singer but a
lousy key for the guitarist. The chorus
to Shania Twain's "Man! I Feel Like A Woman!" is in the key of F and
uses F, Dm, Bb and Gm chords.. A bright jangley open-chord guitar sound on the
chorus would be great, but there is only one open chord in the bunch —Dm. We
need to capo the guitar in a way that lets us play as many open chords as
possible. With the capo on the third fret (Capo III), open chords will sound three half-steps higher, because the capo
shortens all the string lengths by that amount. For this reason, to stay in the
same key as the rest of the band we must play chords that are three
half-steps lower. And how do we find these chords? By looking at the column
of the chart that shows chord letter-names that are three half-steps lower
(-3). The resulting guitar chords are D, Bm, G and Em. The guitarist plays an
open D but the combination of capo position and chord choice produces an F
chord. The G and Em chords are also jangley open chords. Success!
Most folk guitarists are quite familiar with the use of
the capo when composing and playing songs . The usual open chords of C, E, Em,
A, Am D, Dm and G sound great on an acoustic but place obvious limits on where
you can go musically. Using a capo in various positions not only gives you new
chord sounds but allows the singer to use different areas of their vocal range.
James Taylor's 1976 album Greatest Hits
contains many songs that illustrate the usefulness of the capo in creating
variety in key and vocal range. Something in the way she moves is in C,
but by using Capo III Taylor plays the open chords A, D, G and Em7 as if he
were in the key of A. Carolina in my mind is in E, but with Capo II he
can play as if the song is in D, with open chords in the chorus (D-G-Em-A) that
permit his famous hammer-on picking style. Fire and Rain is in C, but
with Capo III the song can be played as if it were in the key of A. By using
the capo James Taylor can vary his vocal approach to a song by placing the
melody in a particular vocal register.
The
bottom line? Changing the key of a song can have a profound effect on the
performance. Use the transposing chart to try songs in different keys and
listen to the result. The song will quickly let you know what works and what
doesn't.
half-steps lower half-steps higher
-6 |
-5 |
-4 |
-3 |
-2 |
-1 |
chord letter |
+1 |
+2 |
+3 |
+4 |
+5 |
+6 |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |
F# |
G |
Ab |
A |
Bb |
B |
C |
C# |
D |
Eb |
E |
F |